|
Police 'illegally' stopping white
people to racially balance stop-and-search figures, watchdog claims
Police are making unjustified and 'almost certainly' illegal
searches of white people to provide 'racial balance' to Government
figures. Lord Carlile, the independent reviewer of terror laws, said he
knew of cases where suspects were stopped by officers even though there
was no evidence against them. He warned that police were wasting time and money by carrying out these 'self-evidently unmerited searches' which were an invasion of civil liberties and 'almost certainly unlawful'. The searches of, for
example, 'blonde women' who fit no terrorist profile come against a
backdrop of complaints from rights groups that the number of black and
Muslim people being stopped by police is disproportionate.Lord Carlile suggests whites are being needlessly stopped in
order to balance the books. Last year, the number of whites searched under anti-terror
laws rocketed by 185 per cent, from 25,962 to 73,967. Whites made up around two-thirds of all those stopped,
although, compared to the overall population, blacks and Asians remain
far more likely to be stopped and searched. Lord Carlile, a Liberal Democrat peer and QC, condemned the
wrongful use of Section 44 of the Terrorism Act 2000 in his annual
report on anti-terror laws. He said police were carrying out the searches on people they
had no basis for suspecting so they could avoid accusations of
prejudice. Lord Carlile wrote: 'I have evidence of cases where the person
stopped is so obviously far from any known terrorism profile that,
realistically, there is not the slightest possibility of him/her being
a terrorist, and no other feature to justify the stop. 'In one situation the basis of the stops was numerical only,
which is almost certainly unlawful and in no way an intelligent use of
the procedure. 'I believe it is totally wrong for any person to be stopped in
order to produce a racial balance in the Section 44 statistics. There
is ample anecdotal evidence this is happening. 'I can well understand the concerns of the police that they
should be free from allegations of prejudice, but it is not a good use
of precious resources if they waste them on self-evidently unmerited
searches. 'It is also an invasion of the civil liberties of the person
who has been stopped, simply to 'balance' the statistics. 'The criteria for section 44 stops should be objectively
based, irrespective of racial considerations: if an objective basis
happens to produce an ethnic imbalance, that may have to be regarded as
a proportional consequence of operational policing.' He added: 'If, for example, 50 blonde women are stopped who
fall nowhere near any intelligence-led terrorism profile, it's a gross
invasion of the civil liberties of those 50 blonde women. 'The police are perfectly entitled to stop people who fall
within a terrorism profile even if it creates a racial imbalance as
long as it is not racist." Officers in England and Wales used the powers to search
124,687 people in 2007/8, up from 41,924 in 2006/7 and only 1 per cent
of searches led to an arrest. Nearly 90 per cent of the searches were carried out by the
Metropolitan Police which recorded a 266 per cent increase in its use
of the power. Lord Carlile said he could see no reason for the whole of
Greater London to be permanently designated an area where the power
could operate. He added: 'I repeat my mantra that terrorism related powers
should be used only for terrorism related purposes; otherwise their
credibility is severely damaged. The damage to community relations if
they are used incorrectly can be considerable.' Shadow Security Minister Baroness Neville-Jones said: 'It is a
hallmark of this Government that powers available under terrorism
legislation are used for reasons entirely unrelated to those for which
they were put on the statute book. 'Inappropriate use of stop and search power is the surest way
to lose public support and damage community relations. Lord
Carlile rightly condemns this. 'The Government needs to make absolutely sure that
anti-terrorism powers are used proportionately and only for
terror-related purposes.' Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Chris Huhne said: 'We
must row back from random and excessive use of stop and search and
reach out to the communities we most rely on for intelligence in the
fight against terrorism.' Home Secretary Alan Johnson said the Metropolitan Police had
already begun to review how Section 44 was used across the whole of the
capital, including a pilot of its more restricted use. Today's report also warns of the continuing terrorist threat
to the UK. Lord Carlile says there is evidence of ‘small, dissent active
and dangerous’ paramilitary groups in Northern Ireland. The Peer also remains pessimistic about ‘the future of international terrorism as promulgated by violent Islamist jihad’. |
© 2009 British People's Party, BM Box 5581, London WC1N 3XX